Set in the London Museum of Brands, Historic Futures hosted a workshop to discuss what the business case is for value chain mapping.
We pondered big questions – when do companies need to know the origin of their products’ raw material components. How do companies become transparent about this? What are the opportunities or problems that arise from knowing?
Why do we even care?
As a first off, I wondered how many people understood the difference between supply chain mapping and value chain mapping. I thought it would help me to be reminded of the differences.
Value chain as a concept was developed by Michael Proter in ‘competitive advantage’. It’s defined as the amount buyers are willing to pay for what a firm provides’ The concept is still unclear to many. To bring value into focus it’s dependent on:
• subjective experience that is dependent on the context (for example a glass of water will be more valuable to a man dying of thirst than to someone clearing up left over water on a restaurant table)
• fulfils a customer experience
• defines a product or service
The key difference between a value chain and a supply chain is that they flow in opposite directions. Value flows from the person or institution that is the recipient of resources. The primary focus in supply chains is on the costs and efficiencies of supply. That is, the flow of materials from their various sources to their final destinations.
The morning was spent considering challenges and opportunities from value chain mapping. But looking back, a lot of what was said came down to supply chain management and not the value chain proposition –that of who the customer is and what do they value? The challenges that are key to demonstrating where a product comes from can be driven by a companies drive for more efficient supply chains and of course legislation (such as the Frank Dodd Act in the US)
It was useful to think of the pressures on why we might care about knowing about where things are sourced from. Examples given were the acceleration of climate change, water stress, and loss of biodiversity. There is also the global wealth distribution gap.
Looking at the business case for value chain mapping it was reiterated that the outcome has to be expressed as money. A clear pathway to profit and demonstrating acceptable RoI was key to building any business case. The question of managing risk and reputation was central to this business case.
The audience was made up of a mixture of academics, consultants, business people and NGOs. Time was limited to discuss the issues raised in detail but there was a sense that getting the customer to care was still a significant challenge. The role of government and legislation was touched upon, but the reality seemed, that unless the drive for more transparency of where products are sourced from is going to be supported across society, the value chain may still be some way off being considered valuable.
Contact us:
Contact us to see how we can support you.
You can opt out of hearing from us at any time using the unsubscribe link in our emails. Read our full privacy policy.