Get in touch: +44 (0) 1273 491423 | hello@ardeainternational.com
Member Account
Menu
  • Home
  • Consultancy
    • Modern Slavery & Supply Chains
    • Sustainable Business
    • Business & Human Rights
    • Business Training, Guides & Toolkits
    • Fees for Environmental And Human Rights Consulting
    • Packages
  • Training
    • Online learning
    • Webinars
    • Workshops
    • Ardea Academy
  • Resources
    • Toolkits
    • Guides
    • Publications
  • Projects
  • About
    • Meet the team
    • Testimonials
    • Partnerships
    • Working with Universities
    • Volunteering
    • Modern Slavery Statement
    • Our Code of Conduct
    • Sustainability Policy
    • Join us
  • Insights
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Consultancy
    • Modern Slavery & Supply Chains
    • Sustainable Business
    • Business & Human Rights
    • Business Training, Guides & Toolkits
    • Fees for Environmental And Human Rights Consulting
    • Packages
  • Training
    • Online learning
    • Webinars
    • Workshops
    • Ardea Academy
  • Resources
    • Toolkits
    • Guides
    • Publications
  • Projects
  • About
    • Meet the team
    • Testimonials
    • Partnerships
    • Working with Universities
    • Volunteering
    • Modern Slavery Statement
    • Our Code of Conduct
    • Sustainability Policy
    • Join us
  • Insights
  • Contact
Home • Insights • Legal Insights • Paradigm shifts – have we been there before?

Paradigm shifts – have we been there before?

By Colleen Theron, Ardea International
30 Jul 2014

About the author

Tri -qualified lawyer, CEO of Ardea International, Lecturer, author, public speaker, passionate about people reaching their potential

I recently attended a workshop held at the UK Law society in London, to discuss the topic of Transactional Corporate Human Rights abuses, hosted by CORE and the BIICL. It was a fascinating afternoon and certainly went in-depth into the subject. Needless to say, there was a lot to take in and I am grappling with what to cover in a single blog.

Given the weight and breadth of the discussions, what struck me most is this need for corporations, governments and in some respects civil society to embrace a paradigm shift. There needs to be a desire coupled with enforceable regulation for companies to behave in a more morally responsible way. But haven’t we been there before?

We can’t deny that multinational companies are powerful economic operations – with annual turnovers larger than some countries’ gross product. They operate in multiple countries-both directly and indirectly, for example through subsidiaries,  commercial partnerships. If anything, their supply chain impacts are likely to have significant global reach.  Multinationals have  access to political and financial power, thereby raising specific challenges to those sectors in society that do not have rights to effective remedies.

The Bhopal disaster was recalled, in which a plant gas leak lead to an unfathomable and still growing number of victims. Thirty years of litigation and justice has not been for the affected families.  But the tragedy is that over 30 years of litigation has still not prevented those continuing to suffer the consequences of their exposure to the toxic gases today. Bhopal was owned and operated by UCIL, majority owned by US based UCC. Today it is a  wholly owned subsidiary of US based Dow Chemical Group. For further discussion around the Bhopal tragedy and developments in Indian law following this event, take a look at a previous blog we published here.

There are several other cases, some more high profile than others,  including Omai, Trafigura, OK Tedi Gold and Copper mine in Papua New Guinea.

In each case the multinational corporations involved employed double standards in their use and promotion of international law.

The fact is that there are legal and jurisdictional obstacles that are needed to overcome corporate involvement in human rights abuses.

Amnesty’s book ‘Injustice Incorporated’ provides a detailed analysis on what is needed to protect public interest and the international human rights framework.

Together with other members of the panel, ideas were raised on how greater access to remedy could be attained.  An underlying assumption is that corporations should apply the UNGPs to ensure that they undertake a human rights assessment of their activities and implement both policies and procedures to address any abuses. It’s clear that many companies, although making statements in their corporate reports, are not properly implementing their policies. It might be because they don’t know how, or simply don’t want to spend the resource in achieving what is required.

Some radical suggestions were put forward nonetheless:

–          making parent or controlling companies legally responsible for human rights abuses arising in their global operations

–          eliminating forum non conveniente, which would deny courts the power to dismiss a case based on the notion that another forum is more suitable

–          ensuring international cooperation and assistance

So, what next? Will we see these suggestions taking hold? Will the shift that’s so needed come about or will we find ourselves in the same place by the time next year’s conference on these issues takes place?

Contact us:

Contact us to see how we can support you.

You can opt out of hearing from us at any time using the unsubscribe link in our emails. Read our full privacy policy.

Post navigation

Last story
Next story
Ask us anything. From simple queries to complex questions, we're always ready to chat with you. Give us a call. +44 (0) 1273 491423
Ardea International
  • About
  • Join us
  • Contact us
  • Membership Account
  • Newsletter Sign up
Our Services
  • Sustainable Business – Toolkits
  • Modern Slavery in your Supply Chain
  • Training, Guides & Tools
  • Ethics and Compliance

Leading Business Beyond Compliance

T +44 (0) 1273 491423
hello@ardeainternational.com

Ardea International
Fieldview • 21 Staples Barn • Henfield • West Sussex • BN5 9PP • United Kingdom

Get social with us

© Copyright 2023

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Accessibility
  • Privacy
  • Disclaimer

Insights & news straight to your inbox

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Insights & news straight to your inbox

Insert/edit link

Enter the destination URL

Or link to existing content

    No search term specified. Showing recent items. Search or use up and down arrow keys to select an item.